Tuesday, June 4, 2013

Don't leave yet.

The other day I read this article about an upcoming vote by the Southern Baptist Convention on whether or not to abandon Scouting after the recent change in membership policy. According to the article, it is a sure thing.

I have already posted (here and here) about my thoughts regarding the new membership policy. I won't go over the whole thing again but, in short, I believe the new policy actually defines homosexual behavior as immoral and contrary to the values of Scouting. (And groups can exclude members based on inappropriate or immoral behavior.) I don't see a problem moving forward with this policy.

I do, however, understand why others want to leave. I applaud those who will stand by their values even if it means ending long-standing friendships and associations. But, I really think that those who have declared an intention to leave the BSA need to re-think that decision.

I encourage everyone to re-read the BSA statement on the membership policy change, the resolution that was voted on, and the points of clarification document associated with it. I believe that a careful reading of these documents will reveal that the BSA has not abandoned it's traditional values, nor does it advance an agenda in any way.

I also understand the fear of what comes next. This issue will come back in relation to adult leaders. There are those who want another change in policy that would essentially define homosexual behavior as acceptable. That would be a problem for me, too. I would not be able to support such a decision.

What that means, then, is that it is time for religious groups to increase their involvement in the BSA rather than decrease it. We need people and churches who are willing to stand up for what is right to become more involved in their districts and councils, and on the national level. We need to have more of an influence over decision making, not less.

I do not believe the BSA has abandoned it's moral tradition with this recent change. But if churches and religious groups leave, we will be weakened. The next time it comes up, there will be fewer who will resist and the changes will be more likely to happen.

Please, don't leave. We need you.


  1. I think that we all agree that any sexual behavior is out of place in Scouting no matter what orientation is being expressed in that behavior. This includes physical "demonstrations of affection" or PDA's between people in a Scouting context regardless of orientation.
    There's nothing in the BSA statements that indicate to me that sexual orientation, no matter what that orientation is, is immoral or bad.

  2. Agreed. It will be a free for all if we do.

  3. Hi Tory! I loved your post as a Varsity District Staff member & as an On Target Coordinator for the GSL Council! I cross-posted your post on the On Target Facebook page...


    We definitely need folks to step-up and help improve things rather than leave!

    John Blackham, ontarget.gslc@gmail.com